Self-Closing Gate or Manual Gate? Which option is best?
Both options are good options but consider the following:
Code compliance:
In most parts of the country self-closing gates are optional, but you should check your local city and county requirements if needed for code purposes since codes can vary and change over time.
Use of the Fence:
Self closing gates are definitely convenient and do significantly reduce the risk of a fence being left open. A manual entrance, where two sections are joined by a section latch, has to be closed every time manually which can be easy to forget if distracted or in a rush. A self closing gate when properly aligned is made to make it easier for parents to enter/exit the pool area and significantly reduce the chance of accidentally leaving the fence open.
Safety:
Both systems have their strengths and weaknesses. For example, the manual entrance has less moving parts. Once a point-lock section is manually latched, you know the barrier is secure. A self closing gate on the other hand, if not properly aligned may not latch. If you are forgetful, the benefits of having a door that shuts behind you may outweigh the added maintenance of keeping the gate functioning properly.
Costs:
Self closing gates costs extra while manual entrances are built into the fence system.
Now that we covered the basics, let’s go over a commonly asked question:
Should a self-closing gate shut 100% of the time?
It should when properly aligned with properly working parts. Every gate can eventually get out of alignment causing latching issues. Temperature changes, fence removal, or even heavy use can be factors leading to misalignment. With proper alignment, the mechanical parts do an excellent job helping keep your fence secure by closing on its own, but nothing can replace double checking to make sure your barrier is secured before leaving it. Mechanical parts are not always perfect on their own and need maintenance over time. Even a toy can get wedged inside your gate preventing it from fully shutting properly so we always recommend to lock your magna latch and remove the key when finished using the pool area to make sure you leave the area/system secure.
In conclusion, whether you need a self-closing gate depends on your local codes and your preference on what you believe will work best for you when it comes to properly using and maintaining your fence.
